Something unusual is developing in New York City: a tense dynamic between Zohran Mamdani and Andrew Cuomo, the two leading candidates competing for mayoral office. And despite Donald Trump’s efforts to sway voters towards Cuomo, Mamdani has continued to eclipse Cuomo in nearly every poll, with Emerson College’s most recent findings placing Mamdani in the lead by 29 points. Cuomo, in comparison to his vibrant foe, is impotent and ineffectual; he cannot compete with his opponent’s vivacity and does not have fresh political viewpoints to disguise his failure to acclimate to this brave new world. It is evident to anyone who has been watching this race with even a minute interest that there seems to be a revelation just out of sight that will define the future of America, and Mamdani is a part of it.
In a way, the vicious dogfight of this New York City mayoral election is a microcosm of the larger political atmosphere. Aging and ailing politicians are using their terminal lucidity to secure their legacies, while younger figures march unceasingly forward. And in this period of troubles, Mamdani represents a beacon of the future. This is not simply because of his youth but rather because of the unwavering optimism that he radiates and his undogged confidence, untouchable even by his most hostile opponents. One might find the dynamic between Mamdani and Cuomo reminiscent of the 1960 presidential debates: of John F. Kennedy’s magnetic charisma in the face of Nixon’s traditional severity, of the rise of a new age, and of the fading of the past. This perception would not be inaccurate.
It is easy to blame senile politicians for the recent political and economic ills that have befallen Americans. And it is not untrue—age indeed contributes. Yet there is a deeper, meaner heart that ticks within American politics, pumping adrenaline through the limbs of our governmental branches and amplifying the voices of protestors and lobbyists. This heart is fear. The fear of war. Of hardship. Of unpaid bills. Fear is the great motivator. To our governing figures, it is the mature, sage response to gridlocks or crises; it is sensibility’s ambitious executor. Fear is the tightrope that keeps us from tumbling into that unknown space where the future lies. New Yorkers—and Mamdani—are tired of the balancing act.
To our aged politicians, Mamdani is more than a mere candidate; he is a threat to both a labyrinthine system of bureaucratic red tape and the strange mystical rulebook that all politicians must follow to delay vital action. American politics rests on a backbone of secrecy; our politicians are brothers of a strange fraternity that has pledged itself to shielding outsiders from the abstruse inner workings of our government. This secrecy protects the heart of fear. Mamdani does not believe in fear. He has left no room to question the veracity of his convictions, having devoted himself entirely to the causes he considers of vital importance. Among these are a hunger strike to end medallion debt for New York taxi drivers, funding increases for public transport, and a successful free bus program. His impassioned vocality has been used for a variety of causes: calling for the arrest of Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu for war crimes, supporting progressive economic programs such as universal childcare, and condemning Israel’s attack on Gaza as a genocide, while his contemporaries remained silent. To Mamdani’s peers, his honesty is a risk. To New York, it is a path toward an auspicious future.
As Mamdani laps Cuomo in popularity, his role in the political landscape becomes clearer—and far more intimidating. As heir apparent to the mayoralty of the most populous city in the country, Mamdani has emerged as the figurehead of Democratic resistance to the reigning radical conservatism that has taken root in American society and politics. If he fails to take up the mantle, his deficiencies will be amplified on the national stage as representative of a decaying Democratic party. He is in a position that is at once immensely promising and incredibly dangerous. Mamdani is running on a novel strategy—proud and unyielding devotion to decidedly socialist policy—that, according to the politician’s playbook, should fail. Instead, he has been met with resounding success. But will Mamdani understand the meaning of New York’s aggressive support?
For Orville Wright, the airplane flies because it “doesn’t have the time to fall.” Here, at the crossroads, we feel it, the turbulence of wrinkled hands claiming what they no longer have. Cuomo’s traditionalist and arcane stance makes him a pawn easily susceptible to Donald Trump’s authoritative influence. Mamdani, to the mature and reserved world of politics, is an abrasively modern figure: an immigrant, a Muslim, a hip-hop fan, and a man passionate about doing away with tradition. He is the determiner of the Democratic Party’s fate. We are teetering on the precipice between old and new, with one foot over the ledge. This is the breaking point. Can Mamdani keep us in the air? Can we trust him with the promise of a new golden age?
Mamdani says we can.
The Skidmore News welcomes all respectful discourse related to this op-ed. If you would like to submit a rebuttal or thoughts related, please contact us here.